New Delhi: The Supreme Court has examined whether the dismissal of an application seeking impleadment under Order I Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) can operate as res judicata against a subsequent application filed under Order XXII Rule 10 in a property dispute.
The case, Sanjiv Kumar v. Shakuntla Devi (2026 SC), concerned a property sold to subsequent purchasers by the defendant while a suit seeking a declaration of ownership was pending before the court.
The subsequent purchasers initially sought impleadment under Order I Rule 10 CPC, claiming that they had stepped into the shoes of the original defendant. The application was dismissed on the ground that the property had been sold in violation of a prohibitory court order, although no such injunction was in force.
The purchasers subsequently filed another application under Order XXII Rule 10 CPC, seeking permission to participate in the proceedings as assignees of the interest in the property.
The legal question was whether the dismissal of the earlier application would bar the subsequent application under the principle of res judicata, particularly when the earlier decision was based on an erroneous factual premise.
The Court observed that the principle of res judicata can apply to interlocutory applications filed at different stages of the same proceedings. It also reiterated that a judicial decision remains binding unless challenged through appropriate legal remedies, even if it contains an error of law or fact, subject to recognised exceptions involving jurisdiction, fraud or collusion.
The Court explained that Order I Rule 10 CPC deals with the addition or deletion of parties who are necessary or proper parties to a suit, while Order XXII Rule 10 CPC addresses situations in which an interest in the subject matter of a pending suit devolves upon another person through a transfer or assignment.
Although the two provisions serve distinct legal purposes, their application may overlap in certain circumstances. Where an earlier application has been decided on its merits and the decision has attained finality, a subsequent application raising the same claim based on the same transfer, interest and facts may be barred by res judicata.
In the present case, the subsequent application under Order XXII Rule 10 CPC was held to be a re-agitation of an issue already decided under a different statutory provision and was therefore considered barred by the principle of res judicata.




